As Nigeria prepares for the 2026 FIFA World Cup playoffs, a fierce debate is emerging among fans and analysts over who should start in goal, Stanley Nwabali or Maduka Okoye, writes Nigeiasoccernet.com.

For nearly a year, Nwabali has been Nigeria’s undisputed No. 1 since breaking into the national team shortly before the 2023 Africa Cup of Nations (AFCON) in Ivory Coast. His composed displays and commanding presence brought much-needed stability to a Super Eagles side that had struggled for consistency in the goalkeeping department.

However, a series of recent mistakes and disciplinary lapses have raised questions about his reliability, opening the door for Okoye’s resurgence to reignite competition for the gloves.

Nwabali’s costly error against Lesotho in the penultimate qualifying round, which led to a conceded goal in a must-win game, left fans frustrated. The Chippa United shot-stopper has also faced criticism for time-wasting antics and unnecessary yellow cards.

Statistically, his form this season has fallen short of expectations. In 10 league appearances, Nwabali has kept only one clean sheet, conceding 17 goals and saving 19 of 33 shots faced.

Meanwhile, Maduka Okoye has been rebuilding his confidence and form at Udinese in Serie A after enduring a tough period both in club and international football. The 24-year-old, who was sidelined for two months earlier this year, has returned impressively,  conceding just six goals in four games, keeping one clean sheet, and saving 12 of 18 shots.

Okoye’s resurgence comes at a critical time. He has not been Nigeria’s first-choice goalkeeper since his infamous blunder in the 2021 AFCON Round of 16 defeat to Tunisia, an error that led to a long absence from the national setup. Though former coach Finidi George recalled him in May 2024, he has yet to reclaim the No. 1 shirt.

Now, with both goalkeepers available, head coach Eric Sékou Chelle faces one of his toughest decisions as the Super Eagles open camp in Morocco ahead of the November 13 semifinal clash against Gabon, and a possible final against either DR Congo or Cameroon three days later.

Despite the growing debate, Chelle has publicly backed Nwabali, emphasizing his commitment and leadership.

“I need players with character,” Chelle told Eagle FM. “Maybe sometimes he needs to relax, but Stanley gives everything for his team and country. He makes mistakes, yes, but his commitment cannot be questioned.”

While Nigerians continue to debate who deserves the gloves, many believe the renewed rivalry between Nwabali and Okoye could ultimately strengthen Nigeria’s goalkeeping department — a crucial factor as the Super Eagles aim to secure their place at the 2026 FIFA World Cup.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement